The market has broadly reached a consensus that the BOJ will raise rates again in December, but views are divided on the terminal rate, and uncertainty over the neutral rate is emerging as a new factor for the yen exchange rate.
The BOJ is expected either to keep its current policy rate of 1.25% unchanged or raise it by 0.25% in December to 1.5%, according to growing market expectations. A Reuters poll found that expectations for the terminal point of the current rate-hike cycle are concentrated in the 1.75%–2.00% range.
The BOJ staff estimate for the nominal neutral rate spans a broad 1.1%–2.5% range, and the lack of agreement among the 9-member committee over which level should be considered neutral is creating uncertainty in the market. The neutral rate, defined as the level that neither stimulates nor restrains the economy, makes it difficult to assess the scope for further rate hikes.
Governor Ueda Kazuo (植田和男) described the recent weakness in consumption as temporary in testimony before the Diet and indicated that consumer spending would recover, supporting expectations of a December rate hike. Differences among committee members over the terminal rate are pronounced: hawkish member Tamura Naoki (田村直樹) argues for a rate of approximately 2%, while fellow hawkish member Takata Hajime (高田創) argues that rates should be raised to around the midpoint of the estimated range.
Two vacancies are expected to arise on the BOJ's 9-member committee next year, and the appointments could become a turning point for monetary policy. Nomura Securities' analysis suggests that the BOJ may target stability around its inflation target without providing clear guidance on the pace of rate hikes. There are also views that if the yen weakens further, developments in the yen exchange rate will continue to directly influence the direction of policy.