The Japan Fair Trade Commission has conducted a compulsory investigation of 4 major beer manufacturers on suspicion of forming a cartel to set prices at the time of shipment, while cases of bid-rigging in large-scale condominium renovation projects and other misconduct across various industries have also come to light. Alongside criticism questioning the limits of Japanese business practices, reports point to the continuing failure to reform long-standing, cosseted customs.
The Japan Fair Trade Commission began a compulsory investigation into 4 major beer manufacturers, Asahi Beer, Kirin Beer, Sapporo Beer and サントリーページ, on suspicion that they had formed a cartel to set prices at the time of shipment. Similar allegations have previously been made concerning the ice cream industry and bid-rigging in condominium renovation projects, indicating that improper trading practices have been identified across a broad range of sectors.
Drawing on his experience as a management consultant, the author points out that cartels and bid-rigging are more likely to occur in industries where product differentiation is difficult. As a specific example, he analyses the beer market, where apparent differences are limited, but differences in advertising expenditure, distribution systems and freshness affect consumers' choices.
During the process of Asahi Beer's expansion of its market share, blind tests highlighted the fact that differences in taste could not be identified, and investment in advertising and supply-chain reforms are said to have produced results. From 1986 onward, the appointment of personnel who promoted organisational reforms and the launch of new products intensified competition in the market, ultimately changing the shares from 50-50.