Risk of losses from litigation and adverse judgments
First written in FY2018. 6 of 17 entries say "Materialised", first in FY2018. Latest entry: FY2024-Q3.
Ferrotec moved to the "Worse" side of this theme in 2018.
0 other companies' latest entry also says "Other".
- FY2024-Q3Finalization of the appellate judgment and completion of payment, and conclusion of separate litigationAnnual report
「On 16 August 2023, the appellate court handed down a judgment ordering payment of a total of ¥113 million (approximately ¥2,320 million) for construction work and other costs, plus delay damages. On 7 September 2023, CCMC paid Yaxiang the construction costs, other amounts and delay damages in accordance with the appellate judgment.」
In CCMC’s cleanroom installation work litigation, the appellate judgment became final and payment of approximately ¥2,320 million and other amounts was made. In separate litigation seeking contractual damages, the appeal was also dismissed, resulting in a final judgment under China’s two-tier court system, although the possibility of a petition for retrial remains. - FY2024-Q1Finalization of the appellate judgment and paymentAnnual report
「On 29 June 2023, the appellate court handed down a judgment dismissing the appeal and upholding the original judgment.」
In the semiconductor wafer plant construction litigation involving CCMC, the appellate judgment concerning the civil engineering construction contract became final. Payment of the construction costs and other amounts in accordance with the judgment was also made. Meanwhile, the disclosure states that the possibility of a petition for retrial or other proceedings remains in separate cleanroom installation work litigation following the appellate judgment, and the litigation matter remains ongoing. - FY2023MaterialisedAnnual report
「On 11 April 2023, in the remand proceedings, a judgment was handed down ordering CCMC to pay Yaxiang ¥111 million (approximately ¥2,114 million) for construction work and other costs, plus delay damages and other amounts. Yaxiang and CCMC appealed the judgment to the Zhejiang Provincial High People's Court in Hangzhou on 26 April 2023, and the case remains pending.」
In the CCMC-related cleanroom construction litigation, a judgment was issued in the remanded proceedings and both parties appealed, with litigation risk continuing to materialize at the judgment and appeal stages. - FY2023-Q3MaterialisedAnnual report
「Of the lawsuits relating to the above refiling, in the action seeking payment under the civil engineering construction contract, the court handed down a judgment on 29 December 2022 ordering CCMC to pay 中建一局 RMB158 million (approximately ¥3,237 million) in construction costs and other amounts, plus delay damages. 中建一局 appealed the judgment to the Zhejiang High People’s Court in Hangzhou on 3 January 2023, and the case remains pending.」
In litigation concerning the construction of a semiconductor wafer plant, a judgment was issued ordering payment of approximately ¥3,237 million, and the opposing party appealed. In separate litigation concerning another claim, CCMC’s claim was dismissed and an appeal is pending, with litigation risk materializing at multiple judgment and appeal stages. - FY2023-Q2Annulment and remand of the appellate judgmentAnnual report
「On 24 May 2022, with the written judgment delivered on 27 May 2022, a judgment was handed down annulling the original judgment and remanding the case to the original court, the Intermediate People’s Court of Hangzhou, Zhejiang Province, on the grounds that the proceedings had been insufficient. The case remains pending.」
In the cleanroom installation work litigation between CCMC and 亜翔, the appellate court annulled the original judgment and remanded the case to the original court, returning it to pending status. - FY2022-Q3MaterialisedAnnual report
「On 12 November 2021, with the written judgment delivered on 25 November 2021, the Intermediate People’s Court of Hangzhou, Zhejiang Province, handed down a judgment ordering CCMC to pay 亜翔 a total of RMB109 million (approximately ¥1,898 million) in construction costs and other amounts, plus delay damages. CCMC appealed the judgment to the Zhejiang High People’s Court on 10 December 2021.」
A judgment ordering payment of approximately ¥1,898 million in cleanroom installation work costs and other amounts to CCMC was issued, and CCMC appealed. Litigation risk materialized in the form of a new judgment. - FY2022-Q2RestatedAnnual report
「All of the lawsuits relating to the above refiling remain pending.」
It was reconfirmed that the litigation concerning the cleanroom installation work and semiconductor wafer plant construction work involving 杭州中欣晶圓半導体 remains pending, even after the claims were reorganized and the lawsuits were refiled. - FY2022-Q1MaterialisedAnnual report
「We received a written judgment dated 8 May 2021, delivered on 14 May 2021, ordering payment of a total of RMB32 million (approximately ¥543 million) in construction costs and other amounts, plus delay damages. As a result, the judgment in this litigation became final.」
In litigation concerning building foundation construction costs and other matters involving 杭州中欣晶圓半導体股份有限公司, a judgment ordering payment of approximately ¥543 million plus delay damages became final. - FY2021-Q2MaterialisedAnnual report
「On 17 August 2020, a judgment was handed down ordering payment of a total of RMB34 million (approximately ¥520 million) in construction costs and other amounts, plus delay damages. We appealed the judgment to the Intermediate People’s Court of Xiaoshan District, Hangzhou, Zhejiang Province, on 14 September 2020.」
In litigation concerning FTHW’s building foundation construction costs and other matters, a judgment was issued ordering payment of approximately ¥520 million, and the company appealed. Litigation risk progressed into a specific event in the form of a judgment. - FY2020WorsenedAnnual report
「Our consolidated subsidiary FTHW was sued by 中建一局集団建設発展有限公司 in the Intermediate People’s Court of Hangzhou, Zhejiang Province, for payment of a total of RMB386 million (approximately ¥6,049 million) for additional and modified construction work and other costs related to the construction of a semiconductor wafer plant. The lawsuit was filed on 6 November 2019, and the complaint was received on 19 December 2019.」
Litigation seeking approximately ¥2,955 million in damages was also filed by FTHW in April 2020, while the ¥6,049 million claim relating to the construction of the semiconductor wafer plant remained pending. A provisional attachment of assets had also been made. - FY2020-Q3WorsenedAnnual report
「Our consolidated subsidiary 杭州中欣晶圓半導体股份有限公司 (hereinafter, “FTHW”) was sued by 中建一局集団建設発展有限公司 (hereinafter, the “plaintiff”) in the Intermediate People’s Court of Hangzhou, Zhejiang Province, for payment of a total of RMB386 million (approximately ¥6,022 million) for additional and modified construction work and other costs related to the construction of a semiconductor wafer plant. The lawsuit was filed on 6 November 2019, and the complaint was received on 19 December 2019.」
In addition to the existing litigation, new litigation was initiated seeking approximately ¥6,022 million for additional and modified construction work and other costs related to the semiconductor wafer plant. A provisional attachment was also placed on the plant’s land-use rights and other assets, but it was stated that this would not impede business operations. - FY2020-Q1WorsenedAnnual report
「As of the filing date of the securities report for the 39th fiscal year, the plaintiff had withdrawn the lawsuit, and this was disclosed accordingly. Subsequently, however, the lawsuit was refiled, so the provision was not reversed and continues to be recognized.」
It became clear that the lawsuit involving 上海漢虹精密機械有限公司 had been refiled after being withdrawn, and that the litigation loss provision had not been reversed and continues to be recognized. - FY2019WorsenedAnnual report
「杭州中芯晶圓半導体股份有限公司, a consolidated subsidiary of the Company, was sued by 中国建築第八工程局有限公司 in the Xiaoshan District People's Court of Hangzhou, Zhejiang Province, seeking payment of a total of RMB48 million (approximately ¥814 million) for building foundation work and other costs. The action was filed on 10 April 2019, and the complaint was served on 28 May 2019.」
The litigation involving 上海漢虹精密機械有限公司, which had been ongoing since the previous fiscal year, was settled and the litigation provision was reversed. However, by the filing date, new litigation had been initiated against 杭州中芯晶圓半導体 seeking payment of ¥48 million. Separate litigation seeking ¥128 million and a counterclaim of ¥69 million were also reported, indicating increased litigation exposure. - FY2019-Q3MitigatedAnnual report
「An agreement to settle the pending litigation involving Shanghai Honghong Precision Machinery Co., Ltd., a consolidated subsidiary of the Company, was reached with the plaintiff during the current third-quarter consolidated accounting period. Accordingly, the difference between the provision recorded in the previous consolidated fiscal year and the settlement costs has been recorded as a reversal.」
The company reached a settlement agreement with the plaintiff in the pending litigation and reversed a ¥407 million provision for litigation losses. The disclosure states that the litigation risk has been reduced. - FY2019-Q2WorsenedAnnual report
「Expense for provision for litigation losses 115,685」
The company recognized an additional provision of more than ¥115 million for pending litigation during the cumulative period of the current quarter, bringing the provision for litigation losses balance to ¥1,229 million. - FY2019-Q1WorsenedAnnual report
「Expense for provision for litigation losses 63,896」
The company recognized an additional expense for the provision for litigation losses of more than ¥63 million in connection with pending litigation, bringing the provision for litigation losses balance to ¥1,197 million. - FY2018MaterialisedAnnual report
「To provide for losses related to pending litigation involving Shanghai HanHong Precision Machinery Co., Ltd., a consolidated subsidiary of the Company, we estimate potential future losses and record the amount deemed necessary as an expense for the provision for litigation losses under extraordinary losses.」
For the pending litigation involving Shanghai HanHong Precision Machinery Co., Ltd., the company recognized a provision for litigation losses and disclosed extraordinary losses of ¥1,114 million and a provision for litigation losses balance of ¥1,158 million.